Pensions Past and Present - What They Mean for Families Today

Pensions have long been a cornerstone of retirement planning, designed to provide financial stability and dignity in old age. In the UK, their evolution reflects changing societal needs, economic challenges, and government reforms aimed at ensuring retirees’ security. However, recent proposals to reintroduce inheritance tax (IHT) on pensions highlight a shift in their role, sparking debate about their place in wealth planning.

The Early Days: Foundations of the Pension System (1908–1946)

The story of UK pensions began with the Old Age Pensions Act of 1908, which came into effect on January 1, 1909—“Pensions Day.” It provided weekly payments of 10 to 25 pence for individuals aged 70 and older, subject to strict conditions such as being of “good character.” While modest, it set a precedent for state-supported retirement.

The Finance Act of 1921 introduced tax relief on pension contributions, incentivising savings by adding the value of forgone income tax to pensions. The landmark National Insurance Act of 1946 established a contributory State Pension, which took effect in 1948. This ensured universal coverage, with men eligible at 65 and women at 60, embedding pensions into the fabric of post-war social security.

Mid-Century Developments: Expansion and Complexity (1946–1988)

Subsequent reforms sought to link pensions more closely with individual earnings. The Social Security Pensions Act of 1978 introduced the State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (SERPS), offering an additional pension tied to earnings. Yet, by the Social Security Act of 1980, the government severed the link between average earnings and State Pension increases, undermining their value over time.

In 1988, personal pensions were launched, providing individuals with more control over their retirement savings. These products complemented existing occupational and state schemes, catering to the evolving needs of a more mobile workforce.

Modern Pension Reforms: From Flexibility to Taxation (1988–2024)

The early 2000s brought efforts to simplify pension saving and enhance flexibility. A-Day in 2006 introduced sweeping changes, allowing individuals to save up to 100% of their income (capped at £215,000 per year) into pensions with full income tax relief at their marginal rate. However, inheritance tax (IHT) applied to any pension funds not in an annuity at the time of death, restricting pensions’ usefulness in estate planning at this time.

In 2015, pension freedoms transformed retirement planning. Savers gained greater control over their defined contribution pensions, including the ability to withdraw funds as income or lump sums post-55. Crucially, the reforms abolished IHT on pensions, and if the holder died before 75, allowed funds to pass to beneficiaries tax-free. After age 75, withdrawals by heirs were taxed only at their marginal rate. These changes elevated pensions as vehicles for both retirement income and intergenerational wealth planning.

Proposed Reintroduction of Inheritance Tax in the 2024 Budget

The October 2024 budget proposed significant changes, reintroducing IHT on pension pots passed to heirs, marking a stark reversal of the 2015 freedoms. This measure aims to increase tax revenues by treating pensions more like other assets in the estate, subjecting them to a 40% tax rate above the £325,000 nil-rate band (plus any applicable allowances).

Pensions and the Role of Intergenerational Wealth Planning

While pensions remain vital for retirement income, the proposed changes diminish their attractiveness as a vehicle for intergenerational wealth transfer. The abolition of IHT on pensions in 2015 unlocked their potential for legacy planning, especially given their tax-efficiency compared to other assets. However, the 2024 proposals reintroduce the complexities and costs associated with passing pensions to heirs, pushing savers to reconsider their financial strategies.

This shift reflects broader policy tensions: balancing the need to secure tax revenues with preserving pensions’ historical role as fair rewards for a lifetime of contributions. For families seeking to optimise their financial legacies, pensions will no longer be the go-to tool they once were.

💬 Curious about the implications of pension reforms for your practice? Let’s talk about how we can help.